Nine ideas about why learning feels hard
None of these is new on its own. Spaced repetition, prerequisite maps and mastery learning are all well studied. Knode's bet is on the combination, and on one claim: learning feels hard mostly because of missing or forgotten pieces, not because any single idea is hard in itself.
What knowledge is made of
- Knodes. Break a body of knowledge into pieces, and the smallest possible piece is a knowledge node, or knode.
- Uniform difficulty. Every knode is about as easy to learn as every other knode.
- Difficulty lives in the network. A knode connects other knodes, and those connect to others still. If something in the network leading up to a knode is missing, you cannot make the connection it asks for, and that is what feels difficult. The knode is not harder. Something beneath it is missing.
- Many useful organizations. The same network can be arranged as a rough hierarchy (what can be learned first and what comes later), as a path (a line through the knodes), or as a cluster (the knodes that make up a lesson, a class, a test or a degree).
Knowing what you know
- Testable. Whether you know a knode can be checked with questions you can only answer correctly if you know it.
How memory behaves
- Predictable forgetting. By modelling your memory, it is possible to make a good estimate of when you will forget a knode.
- Increasing recall period. If you still know a knode when you are tested after some time, you will remember it for longer the next time.
- Review before forgetting. Reviewing a knode before you forget it costs little effort. Reviewing after you have forgotten means learning it again, which costs more time and effort.
The promise
- Never ask for what is forgotten. If you are taken along a path of lessons and questions that never asks you to recall or connect something you no longer remember, the effort and pain of learning and keeping a body of knowledge drops dramatically.
These are theories, and the plan is to test them
Two questions are open. Is every knode really about as easy as every other? And how small does a knode have to be before that holds?
The first test is fifth-grade fractions, a subject many people remember as hard and one where the pieces beneath each step can be named exactly.